The Old Grog

Welcome to The Old Grog, a beloved dining establishment nestled in the heart of Menasha, Wisconsin, at 546 Broad St. This charming locale has been a cornerstone of the community for over three decades, drawing in locals and visitors alike with its delightful blend of history, comfort food, and exceptional hospitality. With a phone number to call ahead for your reservations or inquiries at +1 920-215-6525, it’s never been easier to indulge in what this hidden gem has to offer.

At The Old Grog, the menu is a wonderful reflection of classic American fare that doesn’t just satisfy hunger but warms the soul. From savory sandwiches like the BLT on Texas toast ($8.25) to a hearty Mushroom Swiss with brown gravy ($12.00) and an immense Steak Sandwich ($11.50), there’s something here for everyone. Vegetarian options like the Grilled Cheese Sandwich ($6.75) ensure that all diners leave happy. The hunger pangs don’t stop there—you can dive into a selection of crispy wings, available with an impressive range of sauces that span from the mild Mango Habanero to the tongue-tingling Stinging Honey Garlic.

• Customer Favorites:
• Sunday Chicken Dinner: A succulent offering that has garnered rave reviews for its juicy and flavorful chicken
• Fish Fry Fridays: With perch and walleye, this weekly special has become a tradition for many families.
• Deep Fried Pickles appetizer: A crunchy delight on every table, praised for their perfect balance of crispy batter.

But don’t just take my word for it—visitors like Brad Engel have praised the attentive staff and delicious fish fry, while Collin Groch calls the chicken “the best you’ll ever have” on a Sunday. The friendly atmosphere, where staff like Olivia go above and beyond, makes each meal feel like an occasion.

When it comes to sides, the menu shines with options like Waffle Fries ($4.25) and the extensive Grog Basket ($11.00), a delightful collection of fried goodies begging to be shared. The Macaroni & Cheese ($4.00) is a go-to comfort food which adds a touch of nostalgia with every creamy bite.

The Old Grog isn’t just a meal; it’s an experience—one steeped in local history, vibrant flavors, and an inviting atmosphere. Whether you're stopping in for lunch, dinner, or just to savor a drink at the bar, this restaurant captures the essence of community dining. With such compelling dishes and memorable service, it’s easy to see why The Old Grog continues to be a favorite for many.

So next time you’re in the Fox Valley or simply seeking a new culinary adventure, make your way to The Old Grog. You’re guaranteed a seat at a table with history, where friendly faces and remarkable dishes await you.